| Super Bowl | Date | Result | Winner’s | Total | |
| XLIII | 02/01/09 | Pittsburgh 27, Arizona 23 | +6.5 | 46.5 Over | Santonio Holmes |
| XLII | 02/03/08 | New York Giants 17, Patriots 14 | +12.5 | 54.5 Under | Eli Manning |
| XLI | 02/04/07 | Indianapolis 29, Chicago 17 | -6.5 | 47 Under | Peyton Manning |
| XL | 02/05/06 | Pittsburgh 21, Seattle 10 | -4 | 47 Under | Hines Ward |
| XXXIX | 02/06/05 | Patriots 24, Philadelphia 21 | -7 | 47 Under | Deion Branch |
| XXXVIII | 02/01/04 | Patriots 32, Carolina 29 | -7 | 38 Over | Tom Brady |
| XXXVII | 01/26/03 | Tampa Bay 48, Oakland 21 | +3.5 | 44 Over | Dexter Jackson |
| XXXVI | 02/03/02 | Patriots 20, St. Louis 17 | +14 | 53 Under | Tom Brady |
| XXXV | 01/28/01 | Baltimore 34, N.Y. Giants 7 | -3 | 33.5 Over | Ray Lewis |
| XXXIV | 01/30/00 | St. Louis 23, Tennessee 16 | -7 | 48 Under | Kurt Warner |
| XXXIII | 01/31/99 | Denver 34, Atlanta 19 | -7.5 | 51.5 Over | John Elway |
| XXXII | 01/25/98 | Denver 31, Green Bay 24 | +11.5 | 49 Over | Terrell Davis |
| XXXI | 01/26/97 | Green Bay 35, Patriots 21 | -14 | 49 Over | Desmond Howard |
| XXX | 01/28/96 | Dallas 27, Pittsburgh 17 | -13.5 | 52 Under | Larry Brown |
| XXIX | 01/29/95 | San Fran 49, San Diego 26 | -18 | 54 Over | Steve Young |
| XXVIII | 01/30/94 | Dallas 30, Buffalo 13 | -10.5 | 50.5 Under | Emmitt Smith |
| XXVII | 01/31/93 | Dallas 52, Buffalo 17 | -6 | 45 Over | Troy Aikman |
| XXVI | 01/26/92 | Washington 37, Buffalo 24 | -7.5 | 49 Over | Mark Rypien |
| XXV | 01/27/91 | N.Y. Giants 20, Buffalo 19 | +6.5 | 40.5 Under | Ottis Anderson |
| XXIV | 01/28/90 | San Fran 55, Denver 10 | -11.5 | 47 Over | Joe Montana |
| XXIII | 01/22/89 | San Fran 20, Cincinnati 16 | -7 | 47.5 Under | Jerry Rice |
| XXII | 01/31/88 | Washington 42, Denver 10 | +3 | 47 Over | Doug Williams |
| XXI | 01/25/87 | N.Y. Giants 39, Denver 20 | -8.5 | 40.5 Over | Phil Simms |
| XX | 01/26/86 | Chicago 46, Patriots 10 | -10 | 37 Over | Richard Dent |
| XIX | 01/20/85 | San Francisco 38, Miami 16 | -3.5 | 53.5 Over | Joe Montana |
| XVIII | 01/22/84 | L.A. Raiders 38, Redskins 9 | +3 | 48 Under | Marcus Allen |
| XVII | 01/30/83 | Redskins 27, Miami 17 | +3 | 36.5 Over | John Riggins |
| XVI | 01/24/82 | San Fran 26, Cincinnati 21 | -1 | 48 Under | Joe Montana |
| XV | 01/25/81 | Oakland 27, Philly 10 | +3 | 37.5 Under | Jim Plunkett |
| XIV | 01/20/80 | Pittsburgh 31, Rams 19 | -10.5 | 36 Over | Terry Bradshaw |
| XIII | 01/21/79 | Pittsburgh 35, Dallas 31 | -3.5 | 37 Over | Terry Bradshaw |
| XII | 01/15/78 | Dallas 27, Denver 10 | -6 | 39 Under | Randy White, Harvey Martin |
| XI | 01/09/77 | Oakland 32, Minnesota 14 | -4 | 38 Over | Fred Biletnikoff |
| X | 01/18/76 | Pittsburgh 21, Dallas 17 | -7 | 36 Over | Lynn Swann |
| IX | 01/12/75 | Pittsburgh 16, Minnesota 6 | -3 | 33 Under | Franco Harris |
| VIII | 01/13/74 | Miami 24, Minnesota 7 | -6.5 | 33 Under | Larry Csonka |
| VII | 01/14/73 | Miami 14, Washington 7 | +2 | 33 Under | Jake Scott |
| VI | 01/16/72 | Dallas 24, Miami 3 | -6 | 34 Under | Roger Staubach |
| V | 01/17/71 | Baltimore 16, Dallas 13 | -2.5 | 36 Under | Chuck Howley |
| IV | 01/11/70 | KC 23, Minnesota 7 | +12 | 39 Under | Len Dawson |
| III | 01/12/69 | N.Y. Jets 16, Baltimore 7 | +18 | 40 Under | Joe Namath |
| II | 01/14/68 | Green Bay 33, Oakland 14 | -13.5 | 43 Over | Bart Starr |
| I | 01/15/67 | Green Bay 35, KC 10 | -14 | N/A | Bart Starr |
Categories